THE FACEBOOK ART EXPERT: EVERYBODY KNOWS EVERYTHING
The art world has discovered a remarkable new phenomenon: the Facebook Art Expert.
And apparently, there are thousands of them.
Post a photograph of a painting on Facebook, ask a simple question about its authenticity, and within minutes, the experts arrive.
“Definitely a fake!”
“Absolutely authentic!”
“Worth at least $100,000!”
“I saw something similar at a flea market for $50.”
And my favorite:
“I'm an expert. I've been collecting art for 20 years.”
Wonderful. I've been eating in restaurants for more than 70 years. That doesn't make me a Michelin-starred chef.
What fascinates me is the extraordinary confidence of these people.
They can authenticate a Picasso from a blurry photograph taken with a telephone. They can identify the exact age of an African sculpture without ever touching it. They can dismiss a painting attributed to Rembrandt in approximately four seconds.
And they are NEVER wrong.
Of course, there are genuinely knowledgeable collectors, scholars, dealers, and museum professionals participating in Facebook groups. Some offer excellent observations.
But there is an enormous difference between having an opinion and possessing expertise.
An actual art expert knows that authentication may require examining the work physically, studying its provenance, comparing documented examples, consulting archives, and sometimes conducting scientific analysis.
And even after all that, the answer may remain uncertain.
The Facebook expert has a considerably more efficient method.
He zooms in on the photograph.
Case closed.
Another amusing characteristic is that the less these individuals know, the more categorical their judgments become.
A serious specialist might say:
“I would need to examine the work before reaching a conclusion.”
The Facebook expert announces:
“FAKE! 100%!”
No explanation. No research. No hesitation.
Just capital letters.
I have spent more than four decades in the art world, and one thing experience has taught me is that the more you learn about art, the more you realize how much you still don't know.
I've seen respected experts disagree about important works. I've seen paintings rejected and later reconsidered. I've seen attributions change after decades of scholarly acceptance.
And yet, on Facebook, everything is wonderfully simple.
A photograph, three comments, and a verdict.
The real danger begins when an owner mistakes these confident declarations for professional advice.
A genuine artwork might be dismissed. A questionable work might receive enthusiastic encouragement. And someone could make a serious financial decision based on the opinion of a complete stranger whose qualifications have never been established.
So, by all means, enjoy the discussions. Ask questions. Share photographs. Learn from knowledgeable participants.
But remember something important:
Having a Facebook account does not make you an art expert.
Neither does owning a painting, visiting museums, reading a few auction catalogues, or watching Antiques Roadshow.
And the next time somebody declares your painting authentic—or fake—after looking at one photograph, ask a very simple question:
“On what evidence do you base your conclusion?”
You might be surprised how quickly the conversation ends.
Or perhaps you'll receive the ultimate scholarly response:
“Trust me. I know art.”
And there, ladies and gentlemen, is the problem.
#ArtExpert #ArtAuthentication #ArtCollectors #ArtWorld #FineArt #ArtMarket #FacebookExperts #CrookedArtWorld
Comments