top of page

The Fake on the Wall

2 days ago
3 min read

How forgeries pass through prestigious galleries and major auctions


Imagine paying $842,500 for an Old Master. You take it home with an invoice from one of the world’s best-known auction houses. Five years later, the auction house declares it a modern forgery and refunds your money.

That happened to the buyer of a Saint Jerome sold at Sotheby’s New York in 2012. The catalogue described it as “circle of Parmigianino.” The wording already allowed for uncertainty about who painted it. The later finding raised a more basic question. How old was the painting itself?

The fake on the wall. A conservator examines a framed oil portrait with a magnifying loupe.

A painting can be honestly catalogued with a qualified attribution. An old copy can also be a legitimate collectible when it is described accurately. A forgery is made or altered to deceive. Before bidding, ask which claims the seller is making about the work and what evidence supports each one.

A discovery too good to question

A previously unknown painting by a famous artist is exactly the sort of thing a collector dreams of finding. Add a story about a private collection and put the painting on the wall of an established gallery. Suddenly the gaps in its history can seem like part of its appeal.

That is what makes the Knoedler affair worth remembering. In 2013, art dealer Glafira Rosales pleaded guilty for her role in a scheme that supplied more than 60 fake works of modern art to two New York galleries, including Knoedler. Buyers paid more than $80 million across the scheme. The reported provenance relied in part on a supposed private collector whose identity was withheld.

When I read “private collection,” I ask what can be checked independently. Is there a dated photograph that shows this exact painting? An estate inventory with matching dimensions? An invoice preserved in a dealer’s archive? The owner’s name may be confidential, but a collector can still ask what records the seller has examined and which parts of the story remain unverified.

One trap is counting the same story three times. A gallery description, a later auction catalogue and a certificate can look like three sources. If all three repeat information from the same dealer, you still have one source.

What the paint can tell you

In 2011, Sotheby’s handled the private sale of a portrait presented as a Frans Hals. Years later, testing found twentieth-century synthetic pigments in the ground and paint, including beneath parts of the figure. The analyst concluded that the portrait was a counterfeit, and Sotheby’s refunded the buyer.

The location of the pigment matters. A modern pigment in a small area of restoration tells you something about the restoration. A modern pigment embedded in the original structure of a purported seventeenth-century painting can overturn the attribution. When someone says a work has been “scientifically tested,” ask what was sampled, where it was found and what the report actually concluded.

Five questions I would ask before buying

1. What exactly are you selling me? Read the attribution and the sale’s definitions. “By,” “attributed to,” “circle of” and “after” carry different claims. A signature may be listed as a physical feature without establishing who applied it.

2. What is the earliest independently verifiable record of this specific work? Ask for documents you can tie to the object through photographs, dimensions, inscriptions or labels.

3. Can I see the back and the full condition report? The reverse, edges and support can reveal repairs, replaced components or labels that deserve a closer look. Ask about any technical examination already performed.

4. Who has examined it in person? If a recognised specialist’s opinion is cited, ask whether it is written, whether it concerns this exact object and whether the specialist saw the work or reviewed photographs.

5. What happens if the attribution is challenged after the sale? Ask for the guarantee in writing. Check which catalogue language it covers, the deadline for making a claim and what evidence the seller requires.

Over more than forty years in art expertise, I’ve learned to pay particular attention to the painting I most want to believe in. If I’ve already imagined it hanging in my home, I’m more likely to accept a gap in the provenance or give a familiar signature too much weight. That is precisely when I want a second opinion.

Before you bid, ask yourself one question. If the artist’s name disappeared from the catalogue tomorrow, how much would I still pay for this painting?

Does a painting you own deserve a closer look? My $50 preliminary screening reviews the photographs and information you submit and helps you decide whether further authentication research is warranted.

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page