top of page

FACEBOOK ART EXPERTS: THE ARROGANCE OF IGNORANCE!

1 day ago
5 min read

Facebook has become the world's largest gathering of self-proclaimed experts. And the most dangerous ones are often those who know absolutely nothing but are convinced they know everything.

Every single day, Facebook is flooded with fake news, fabricated stories, manipulated photographs, conspiracy theories, and complete nonsense.

And yet, astonishingly, people continue to trust complete strangers who suddenly declare themselves experts in medicine, finance, politics, and, of course, ART.

Are people really that naive?

Don't misunderstand me. I enjoy Facebook.

For me, it is an extraordinary laboratory of human behavior. I can observe how people from all over the world think, behave, love, hate, dream, argue, and express their political opinions.

Sometimes fascinating. Often entertaining. Occasionally frightening.

But I would NEVER take financial advice from a self-appointed Facebook investment guru.

I would NEVER trust a medical diagnosis from a Facebook doctor whose qualifications I cannot verify.

And I certainly would NEVER entrust the authentication of an important work of art to some anonymous individual hiding behind a Facebook profile and a keyboard.

THE FACEBOOK ART EXPERT: A NEW SPECIES OF GENIUS

Every day, someone posts a photograph of a painting or sculpture and asks a perfectly legitimate question:

"Could this be authentic?"

And then the circus begins.

Within minutes, the self-appointed experts descend like vultures.

"FAKE!"

"ABSOLUTELY AUTHENTIC!"

"WORTH MILLIONS!"

"GARBAGE!"

No examination. No serious research. No provenance investigation. No scientific analysis.

Just an oversized ego and an internet connection.

And the extraordinary thing is that these people are apparently specialists in EVERYTHING.

Picasso? Of course.

Rembrandt? Naturally.

Fourteenth-century Italian primitives? No problem.

African reliquary figures? Experts.

Chinese porcelain? Experts.

Egyptian antiquities? Experts.

Contemporary art? Experts again.

WHAT AN EXTRAORDINARY COLLECTION OF UNIVERSAL GENIUSES!

The Louvre, the Metropolitan Museum, and the world's great auction houses should immediately dismiss their specialists and recruit these Facebook prodigies.

Think of the savings!

No more research departments. No more laboratories. No more archives.

Just a smartphone and a few Facebook comments.

FIFTY YEARS IN THE ART WORLD — AND APPARENTLY I KNOW LESS THAN THEY DO!

I have spent 50 YEARS in the international art business.

Five decades examining paintings, studying artists, investigating authenticity, researching provenance, following auctions, and dealing with collectors, galleries, and institutions.

And do you know what I have learned?

THAT I WILL NEVER KNOW EVERYTHING.

I still learn something new almost every day.

Sometimes I discover that something I believed years ago was incomplete or even wrong.

That is called experience.

That is called intellectual honesty.

And that is how genuine expertise develops.

Meanwhile, some Facebook experts apparently acquired their universal knowledge during a coffee break.

I needed 50 years to understand how much I don't know. They needed five minutes on Google to become authorities on everything.

Congratulations!

IGNORANCE IS NOT THE PROBLEM. ARROGANCE IS.

There is absolutely nothing shameful about not knowing something.

Nobody can know everything.

A serious specialist might devote an entire career to Picasso. Another to Renaissance painting. Another to African sculpture, or even to a very specific group of reliquary figures.

And even after decades of research, these specialists can disagree.

That is perfectly normal.

What is NOT normal is somebody who has never examined an artwork, never studied its history, and perhaps never handled an important original, announcing publicly:

"THIS IS A FAKE. 100%."

Based on what?

A photograph?

A signature?

A vague resemblance to something seen on the internet?

An opinion without evidence is not expertise. It is noise.

And shouting that opinion in capital letters doesn't make it more intelligent.

THE DANGEROUS CONSEQUENCES OF FACEBOOK IGNORANCE

Here is where the entertainment stops.

A careless declaration can have consequences.

An authentic painting might be publicly dismissed as a fake.

A worthless imitation might be enthusiastically promoted as a masterpiece.

An owner might abandon legitimate research because some loudmouth on Facebook assured him that his artwork was worthless.

Or, even worse, someone might spend serious money because a group of amateur commentators convinced him that he had discovered a lost Picasso.

These are not harmless little games when people's property and money are involved.

And there is something particularly disturbing about individuals who publicly destroy the credibility of an artwork without presenting a single piece of serious evidence.

They are not necessarily exposing fraud.

Sometimes they are simply advertising their own ignorance.

A REAL EXPERT DOES NOT NEED TO PRETEND TO KNOW EVERYTHING

Let me be perfectly clear.

There are excellent art historians, scholars, dealers, conservators, and experienced collectors on Facebook.

I have great respect for them.

But the genuinely knowledgeable ones usually share one essential quality:

THEY KNOW THE LIMITS OF THEIR KNOWLEDGE.

They are capable of saying:

"I don't know."

"This is outside my specialty."

"I would need to examine the work."

"Another specialist would be better qualified."

Those four sentences demonstrate more professional integrity than a thousand arrogant Facebook declarations.

Recognizing the style of Picasso does not make you a Picasso authenticator.

Owning African art does not automatically make you an authority on every African culture.

Reading auction catalogues does not turn you into an art historian.

And visiting museums does not qualify you to authenticate everything hanging on their walls.

KNOWING A LITTLE ABOUT MANY THINGS IS NOT THE SAME AS KNOWING A GREAT DEAL ABOUT ONE THING.

MY MESSAGE TO THE FACEBOOK ART EXPERTS

By all means, express your opinions.

Discuss paintings. Share discoveries. Ask questions. Challenge attributions.

That is how knowledge grows.

But stop pretending that every opinion you express is an established fact.

Stop confusing confidence with competence.

Stop treating the property of strangers as an opportunity to demonstrate your imaginary superiority.

And above all, STOP DECLARING ARTWORKS FAKE OR AUTHENTIC WITHOUT SUFFICIENT EVIDENCE.

If you are genuinely qualified, explain your reasoning.

Show your research.

Identify your sources.

A serious argument deserves consideration, even when I disagree with it.

But if your entire contribution consists of shouting "FAKE!" beneath a photograph, don't expect me to confuse that with scholarship.

MY CONCLUSION AFTER 50 YEARS

The art world is complicated, fascinating, sometimes dishonest, and always full of surprises.

It requires patience, curiosity, skepticism, and above all, humility.

I have met extraordinary scholars who devoted their lives to understanding a single artist.

And I have met Facebook commentators who apparently understand the entire history of art before finishing their morning coffee.

The difference is simple:

A genuine expert is constantly questioning what he knows.

A wannabe expert is constantly announcing what everybody else should believe.

After 50 years, I am still a student of art.

And I intend to remain one.

As for the Facebook experts who know absolutely everything?

I have only one question:

IF YOU ARE REALLY THAT BRILLIANT, WHY ARE YOU WASTING YOUR GENIUS IN FACEBOOK COMMENT SECTIONS?

Perhaps the world's museums simply haven't discovered you yet.

Or perhaps — and this is just a possibility — your greatest masterpiece is the image you have created of yourself.

Gerard Van WeyenberghArt Expert — 50 Years in the International Art World

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
The Fake on the Wall

How do art forgeries reach leading galleries and auction houses? Gérard Van Weyenbergh examines documented cases and shares five questions to ask before buying.

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page